The record
235 years of nothing.
A complete history of the Third Amendment, from its origins in seventeenth-century England to its present role as a punchline. Every entry but the last one is real. We checked.
Live counter
Days since a federal appeals court last took the Third Amendment seriously
Counting from Engblom v. Carey, Second Circuit, May 3, 1982.
The Petition of Right
Parliament complains to Charles I that soldiers have been forced into private homes, noting “the inhabitants against their wills have been compelled to receive them into their houses.” The key phrase, we note, is against their wills. We are asking for your will.
SourceThe English Bill of Rights
Lists “quartering soldiers contrary to law” among the offenses of James II. The English solved this by writing a law. Our movement also proposes writing a law.
SourceThe Quartering Act
Parliament requires the colonies to house British troops in inns, livery stables and ale-houses. Note: ale-houses. The original quartering crisis was, in large part, soldiers being sent to bars.
The Quartering Act, again
One of the “Intolerable Acts.” Allows troops in uninhabited houses, out-houses and barns. Colonists find this intolerable. In fairness, it was a barn.
SourceThe Declaration of Independence
Among the grievances against George III: “For Quartering large bodies of armed troops among us.” Large bodies. We are proposing one, maybe two, medium bodies per household.
SourcePatrick Henry gets dramatic
At Virginia’s ratifying convention, Henry warns that without protection, soldiers “may be billeted in any manner—to tyrannize, oppress, and crush us.” Our soldiers will be billeted in the manner of a guest room with a nice duvet.
SourceRatified
The Third Amendment joins the Bill of Rights. It immediately begins doing nothing, a streak it will maintain for two centuries.
Wars happen. Nobody sues.
Troops are lodged in private homes during the War of 1812 and the Civil War. No court ever tests the amendment. The Third, by this point, is used to it.
Rent control is not soldiers
In United States v. Valenzuela, a landlord argues that federal rent control amounts to quartering “storm troopers” in his building. A federal court disagrees.
SourceThe amendment gets a cameo
In Griswold v. Connecticut, Justice Douglas lists the Third among the “penumbras” that create a right to privacy. This is the closest it has come to a starring role at the Supreme Court.
SourceThe parade case
In Jones v. Secretary of Defense, Army reservists argue the Third Amendment lets them skip a parade. A federal court in Minnesota disagrees. They march.
SourceEngblom v. Carey
During a 1979 New York prison guard strike, National Guardsmen are housed in the striking guards’ staff residences. The Second Circuit holds that Guardsmen are soldiers, tenants can be owners, and the amendment applies to the states. The only real Third Amendment ruling of note. On remand, the officials get qualified immunity. Nobody gets anything.
SourceNot the sky, either
In Custer County Action Ass’n v. Garvey, the Tenth Circuit rules that military flights over your land are not quartering. The amendment protects the house. Not the airspace. Not the vibe.
SourceThe Onion weighs in
“Third Amendment Rights Group Celebrates Another Successful Year.” Satire has been making our case for nearly two decades.
SourceMitchell v. City of Henderson
Police in Nevada occupy a family’s home to watch a neighbor. The family sues under the Third Amendment. The court rules “a municipal police officer is not a soldier for purposes of the Third Amendment.” The one modern chance, gone.
SourceGorsuch, under oath
At his confirmation hearing, the future Justice tells a room full of senators, “Stay out of my house with your troops.” See The Opposition.
The Third Amendment Gang has its moment
After National Guard troops are moved out of D.C. hotels, Third Amendment memes trend nationally. A Facebook group called “Third Amendment Rights Supporters,” founded in 2010, finally has something to talk about.
SourceThe eviction brief
The Third Amendment Lawyers Association, a joke group of real lawyers, files an amicus brief arguing the CDC eviction moratorium amounts to quartering. The court never gets around to it. As is tradition.
SourceA cameo in Illinois
In Illinois v. Trump, a fight over National Guard deployments to Chicago, a federal court order nods to the Third Amendment’s ban on peacetime quartering. A mention. In a footnote of history. Again.
Repeal the Third is founded
A (fictional) retired vice principal in Sandusky, Ohio reads the Bill of Rights all the way through and has an idea. You are looking at it.
Be part of the next entry